hobbit the legend of bad cgi

[sparksy]

sorry got the title wrong there its the desolation of smeg or whatever.... i gave up after half an hour. the orcs looked like they were out of a ps2 game cut scene... the actors were running towards a river then were in the woods ??? really bad editing... and when they were on the hillside talking about the werewolf thingy the set looked like a bad 1960 start trek episode... so i gave up

[skeletor]

Sounds surprising. Are you sure you were watching a DVD release and not a pre-release?

[BlacKBlazE]

I don't know what you watched but the 1080p version I watched was good!
It must have been a bad copy?

[sparksy]

could be the case .... the file was pretty big... like 17gb .... i must admit i was suprised at how bad it looked.... mind yyou those lord of the rings storys always pissed me off at school... i only wanted to be good ar break dancing at the time...... but at 6ft tall and built like a block of salt i found drinkinking easyer damn im drifting off here i can tell...........

[BlacKBlazE]

[Revolver]

I saw the HFR version at cinema. Certainly wasn't dodgy CGI. It's not everyone's taste but it doesn't look bad. The scene outside the prancing pony at the start was incredibly life like. It was like looking at it though a window.